ARC, Books, Quotes

Book 179: The Suitors – Cécile David-Weill

David-Weill, Cecile - The SuitorsAfter my amazing luck with John Boyne’s The Absolutist last year, I decided to always keep an eye on Other Press releases and I’m glad I did. I requested a copy of this book directly from the publisher and I quite enjoyed it. This is my honest response and I received nothing in return.

To start, I’d like to say that the only other review on Goodreads is worthless (to me, at least). Why bother reviewing a book if that’s all you’re going to say? The person has, in essence, re-written the synopsis of the novel (on the back cover), without any additional insight or synthesis and it came across as snide to me. If you didn’t want to read “frothy froth about rich French people and their angst,” then why’d you read it? It never pretended to be anything else and that’s why I appreciated this novel. It’s times like this when I wish I could give half stars on Goodreads because it’s not quite what I would consider 5 stars, but not quite as low as 4 stars. Now on to my response.

This novel is everything that it claims to be, an amusing inside look at the codes, manners, and morals of high society, and it’s nothing more.So if you don’t want to read a comedy of manners, then don’t. It’s sort of what I imagine Austen’s works were like when they were first published and reactions were similar to the Goodreads reviewer’s.

Now don’t get me wrong, Austen is in a league of her own, but I felt David-Weill did a great jog overall and held her own in ‘high society’ literature. Although the language wasn’t as beautiful, I thought of Muriel Barbery’s The Elegance of the Hedgehog (which I need to reread) and I don’t think you’d be too far a miss to compare the two. In addition I appreciated that the story was broken up based on days and meals and that menus (and recipes!) were included. I love a book that mentions a lot of food and then includes the recipes, a la Frances Mayes.

I worried going into the novel that I wouldn’t appreciate this book as the majority of the high society and comedy of manners novels I read are at least 100 years old. However, I did enjoy it and appreciated David-Weill’s witticisms and observations such as the following,

“Knowing people can mean so many things. It’s like books: there are plenty of gradations between the books one has read and those one hasn’t. There are the books one has heard of, those with a plot or style we already know by heart, those we can tell by their cover, those whose jacket copy we’ve read. Those we want to read and those we never will. One can also read a book and forget it—in fact, that’s my specialty—or just skim through it. It’s the same way with people.” (29)

This isn’t the first time I’ve read a comparison of people to books, but this is one of the better explained versions.

What I was most worried about was the celebrity/celebutant culture overtaking the high society culture, but thankfully it didn’t. The narrator, Laure, had a distinct voice and I thought provided great observations of how she grew up (and lives) with the new money celebrities and business men without coming across as hoity-toity.

There were two things I didn’t really like about the novel, but they weren’t so much as to put me off completely from the novel. The ending was lack-luster and I felt just sort of dropped off even though it gave a bit of room for hope/romance. If David-Weill had left the last chapter without the ending thank you note thing it would’ve been a much stronger, seeming happier, ending.

In addition I struggled to identify with any characters other than Laure which was a bit problematic because there were some amazing minor characters that had so much potential! I completely understand that this is one summer in the many year’s of their lives, but the many minor characters were so transient that even those that were there all the time left me wanting more.

Recommendation: If you like high society novels or self-reflective works then you should definitely check this out. If you want a beach read, as that Goodreads reviewer says, you should also check this out. It’s a novel you can read as much, or as little, into it as you want.

Opening Line: “It was a Sunday like any other.”

Closing Line: “Which reminds me of Jean the gardener’s mower and rake, their sound track tolerated for its regular hours, like a mechanical angelus in the monastic order of lawns…” (Whited out.)

Additional Quotes from The Suitors
“I have always tried to be a decent person, with a code of ethics that drives me to improve and even perfect myself in every way, and I feel it is essential that everyone should have this same aspiration. At the same time, I feel equally strongly that religion, which I believe demands no creativity from its passive, obedient followers, appeals chiefly to imbeciles. In general as stultifying as television, religion, can nevertheless provide matter for reflection, on equal footing with philosophy and the other human sciences. Thanks to Jung, though, I still remained convinced that God—or fate—was nothing more than our unconscious.” (358-9)

“I thought about the end of a love affair, about how we make love with someone without realizing that it’s for the last time, because nothing tells us solemnly that this moment will never come again, a moment we often try in vain to recall later on, when the affair is over.” (393)


14 thoughts on “Book 179: The Suitors – Cécile David-Weill”

  1. I’m curious about the ending–just dropped off. I’m picturing someone coming home from a date and just being dropped off on the curb with no kiss, hug, or anything.


    1. Haaahaa, it sort of was. I mean there was a little bit of closure, but considering how much the the story was built up around one thing it just felt dismissed with a line. There was at least hope for the future for the protagonist, but the rest I was like hmmm well okay.


      1. Thanks Geoff: Just popped over from Goodreads after reading your review. I am just about to start with this one, and I agree with your comment about the quality of books we are seeing from Other Press. Are you going to read the next Boyne, BTW?


        1. Hi Guy, thanks for stopping by and for the comment. This one is an interesting read, I really appreciated it but felt abandoned at the end. I’m sure I will read the next John Boyne, but a lot of it depends on the subject matter for me, so who knows!


  2. I really hate it when people leave unhelpful Goodreads reviews. Especially when they give a book a 1 star rating and state in their review that they “just couldn’t finish it” or “didn’t get past page 10.” Maybe the book would have gotten better or they could have at least gleaned something useful if they stuck it out? People who merely restate the book synopsis annoy me with nearly equal measure.


    1. I agree! It’s disappointing when people do that and feel they have some right to rate the book. Goodreads should provide a DNF option or people should have the common sense to just remove the book from their read list because clearly they didn’t read it. They also don’t need to rate it! I finish every book I start even if it takes forever.


      1. Agree 100% I also finish every book I start (although it’s painful sometimes). I think in addition to DNF option, I’d like a half-star option. There many times I’m torn between two ratings (especially in the 3-4 star range), and I feel like half-stars would making the rating system more accurate.


        1. Yes! Half stars are the most necessary I think. I always feel bad down rating a book because I don’t want to give it that extra half star to make it go up, which is funny because those are arbitrary to me. I only started it to see if Goodreads would give me any good recommendations and it hasn’t really yet.


Let me know your thoughts!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.