Books

Book 127: Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets – J.K. Rowling

Two down, five to go! So my month of bucking reading challenges may be a little longer than a month. I’m totally finishing the series again before I move on to anything else! On to the response!

SO MANY HINTS AND REFERENCES to the later novels its unreal! This time as I’m reading, I’m not finding as much I haven’t found before, but it keeps striking me how many hints and details there are in these first few novels that she carries through the entire series. Just one example is the cabinet Peeve’s smashes to get Harry out of Filch’s office. I mean seriously, that doesn’t make an appearance again until Book 6, but it and it’s partner are both in this book!

This book, unlike Book 1, would probably be in the bottom half of the series in my imaginary rankings. Not for any particular reason, but because I’m just not head over heels in love with it. It’s a great story and it’s actually a better stand alone story than some of the other novels, but in general it’s just a good filler in the series.

When I read any novel, I am always drawn to the power of the minor characters – the characters whose names you might not remember and those who have bit parts that truly fill out the story. This is something Rowling does extremely well. There are so many people in the magical world (and even in the muggle world) that Rowling gives personalities to and slowly fleshed them out throughout the series and I honestly believe they make the books a better reading experience.

If there is one thing that the films didn’t do, for me, it was this. They had to cut so many of the minor characters that I was incredibly disappointed in them at first. It took me until the fifth film to fully remove them from the books and appreciate them as adaptations and not literal visuals. I’m still grumpy they removed some of the characters, Peeves, for one, and gave less screen time to some they really could have fleshed out, the Dursley’s, but overall once I got over the fact they weren’t going to do a literal adaptation I realized most of the films were pretty decent. (I’ll discuss when I get to the later books, my thoughts on how Rowling’s writing style changed to fit the films.)

Recommendation: READ IT. There’s no question about reading all of them. I might not be as enthusiastic about this book as I am about others, but I have friends and know there are people out there who LOVE this novel.

Opening Line: “Not for the first time, an argument had broken out over breakfast at number four, Privet Drive.”

Closing Line: “And together they walked back through the gateway to the Muggle world.” (Whited out.)

Advertisements

9 thoughts on “Book 127: Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets – J.K. Rowling”

    1. That’s really interesting. Those (second and fourth) are probably my least favorite of the books, although they weren’t always. I think the films did good jobs, but for me the film that synched it was the third, and that’s after going back and seeing it years after I first saw it in the theatre.

      Like

      1. I liked the third film too – I think it captured the magic of the HP world more then any of the others. However it left out a big chunk of storyline from what I remember – about Snape and James Potter which was never fully explained. I think sometimes the films concentrated more on big bangs and special effect and less on actually telling the story. I get they can’t do everything that is fair enough – but sometimes you wonder if they ever bothered tor read the books and think about what might be important to portray.

        Like

        1. Definitely! There was so much left out and that’s why I originally hated it and didn’t really appreciate it until much later after it was released in DVD.

          Like

  1. I wonder how many clues I missed when I read them. It would be interesting to read them again in a few years. Enjoy ignoring the reading challenges!

    Like

    1. It’s crazy how many there are. This most recent re-read hasn’t shown me any specific details but there are events that have a completely different meaning like I mention in my post tomorrow.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s