ARC, Random

My First Advance Reader’s Copy

The (not very exciting) Back Story
A little over a month ago someone filled out my Recommend a Book form.  I didn’t think anything of it as mostly the recommendations I get are from Tom and Alie telling me to read the Twilight series, or my own entries reminding me of titles I want to look into.

However, this time I was wrong.  I’d received a REAL book recommendation and not just any book recommendation, but an offer of an Advance Reader’s Copy.  Not knowing 100% what this meant I scoured my brain because I’d read mention of them on a blog before and I was correct.  Thanks to Bev and her review policy over at My Reader’s Block, I was able to figure out a few things (with her kind help answering some random questions by email), I decided to go for it.  So I contacted Christine at Henry Holt and Company and within two weeks my very first Advance Reader’s Copy of a novel arrived in my mailbox.

I believe Christine recommended the book, The Land of Decoration by Grace McCleen*, because of my multiple Emma Donoghue reviews; and since the book received a cover quote from Emma Donoghue and had a child narrator and reminded me of a cross between Roddy Doyle’s Paddy Clarke Ha Ha Ha and Zaddie Smith’s White Teeth, I thought why not give it a go (there were also mentions of similarities to Jeanette Winterson’s Oranges are not the Only Fruit). I will post my review of the novel tomorrow afternoon and get to these comparisons and my thoughts.

On reading my first Advance Reader’s Edition
This was probably the most interesting facet of reading an Advance Reader’s Copy of an unpublished novel.  It is just that, an unpublished, unfinished work.  I mean the majority of it is there, the text, the chapter titles, etc.  However, there are two main things which differentiate this edition from the first published edition:

  1. This is a paperback review edition – uneven pages (quaint), a welcome note/message, and notes on front and back cover distinguishing this as a review copy (above and to the right).  I believe I fall under Online Promotions and Reviews (how cool am I?
  2. The work hasn’t been copy edited or received final proof. Now the copy editor in me (I took a course I’m allowed to call myself that) found this jarring at first, but then the reader in me found it exciting! The most exciting of which was when I found a chapter titled ‘Chapter TBN.’ It took me longer than it should have but I finally realized it was ‘to be named’ and this was like WHOA this book is not completely finalized yet. Throw this in with the occasional spelling mistakes and the warning on the back cover that this is an uncorrected proof and all quotes should be checked against the finished book, I thought it was really interesting!

Overall it was a great experience.  The excitement of receiving a book that wasn’t published (and that I didn’t have to pay for) definitely outweighed the book’s appeal at first.  However, I waited until I finished reading the book I was reading at the time and the luster wore off and I was able to approach the novel as any other. The process was simple enough to get the novel from the publisher (it helps they reached out to me), and as you’ll see in my review tomorrow, I did enjoy the novel.

*I have not received (and will not receive) any compensation for my review.  I received the novel directly from the publisher and the views in this post and the following posts concerning Grace McCleen’s The Land of Decoration are my honest opinions and have not been influenced by those involved in writing, creating or publishing the book. To learn more about the Federal Trade Commission’s guidelines on Endorsements and Testimonials (including bloggers) click here.


9 thoughts on “My First Advance Reader’s Copy”

    1. Haahaa – well I was wondering if it was suggested because I don’t ever really give a harsh review. Even if I find I really dislike a book I can find something good to say about it! It helped that I found this book intriguing because of the comparisons I read about before I agreed to read it.


    1. Haahaa – well I still don’t think I’m that good. I mostly just post reactionary responses and offer an honest opinion. You should check out Net Galleys (for digital copies you can request) I saw it on someone else’s blog the other day. You can request advanced digital copies of books from all genres and a lot of publishers.


  1. Ok Geoff, now you have to check out, I have read a couple of ARC’s but never really had the explanation that it might be full of errors or sloppy writing that looks like “I’ll come back and revise this later” – see my latest post on ‘The Book of Lost Fragrances’ yesterday.

    So thank you for this explanation, my copy was on kindle so strange things like two words on a line here and there and sentences starting with lower case, but the worst were those blunt unfinished sentences I mention, I did try not to sound too negative, hopefully I only come across as being naive 🙂

    I write about what I read for fun, but was enticed by the possibility of not having to wait for the paperback version and having received a kindle for Christmas, I can also read ‘beta-reads’ by converting them into pdf’s.
    I look forward to reading your review.


    1. I knew I’d read about somewhere recently. And now it makes sense! I saw your post but didn’t make the connection until you wrote today. I don’t know how I’d feel about a digital copy, if I really get into reading/requesting advanced copies I may have to switch over to digital to make life easier.


Let me know your thoughts!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.